The 2025 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs are here, and that means it’s time to dig into betting odds, fantasy hockey advice, and potential upsets with sharp insight. On this episode of The Cheat Sheet, George Nassios and Andrew McInnis broke down key playoff matchups, top bets, and fantasy picks that every NHL fan and bettor should keep an eye on.
Here’s a full breakdown of what was discussed — from underdog value plays to future fantasy hockey sleepers.
Do the Devils Have a Chance Against the Hurricanes?
The show kicked off by asking if the New Jersey Devils can upset the Carolina Hurricanes. While the Canes have more playoff experience and are heavy favorites, the Devils do bring speed and young talent to the ice. Nassios noted that while New Jersey might steal a game or two, a full series win looks unlikely. Bettors might look at the “series goes 6 games” prop for better value.
Dallas Stars (+104) vs Colorado Avalanche (-125)
This is one of the most evenly matched series in the West. The Stars are slight underdogs, and both hosts agreed that Dallas presents excellent value. With scoring depth, playoff-tested players, and solid goaltending, backing Dallas at plus odds might be one of the smartest first-round plays on the board.
Betting the Battle of Ontario Series Length
With Toronto and Ottawa set to renew their fiery rivalry, betting on the series to go the distance could be profitable. McInnis highlighted that the emotions and energy in this series often make it unpredictable, suggesting betting “Over 5.5 games” or “Series goes 7” could be ideal.
Best Bets in the Battle of Florida
The Florida Panthers and Tampa Bay Lightning are expected to bring another heated playoff matchup. Nassios suggested targeting goal totals and player props — especially shots on goal and power-play points. A tight series is expected, with value on game-by-game betting instead of full series odds.
Can the Blues (+188) Compete with the Jets (-230)?
The St. Louis Blues come in as heavy underdogs, but they finished the regular season hot. While Winnipeg has a strong edge in goaltending and defense, McInnis pointed out that the Blues could stretch this series further than expected. Bettors may want to explore “Winnipeg in 6” or “Series Over 5.5 games” for plus money.
Minnesota Wild (+195) vs Vegas Golden Knights (-240)
Minnesota is another team getting overlooked by the oddsmakers. Though Vegas holds the edge in depth and recent success, the Wild have dangerous scorers and a style that can frustrate skilled opponents. Taking Minnesota +1.5 on the series line or game-by-game moneyline bets could offer smart returns.
Can the Kings Upset the Oilers?
With the Kings priced at +116 against the -146 Edmonton Oilers, McInnis believes there’s decent upset potential. LA’s defense and goaltending might slow down Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl just enough to swing momentum. The Oilers remain favorites, but the Kings are definitely a live underdog.
Early Conn Smythe Bet: Jack Eichel at +1700
Looking for a long-shot Conn Smythe Trophy pick? Jack Eichel at +1700 could be a steal if the Golden Knights go deep. He’s been consistent and dangerous all season, and he’s poised to lead Vegas through another potential Cup run.
Fantasy Keeper League Debate: Jake Sanderson or Lane Hutson?
In the fantasy segment, Nassios and McInnis debated the long-term value of two promising defensemen: Jake Sanderson and Lane Hutson. While both are excellent prospects, Sanderson’s more complete game and top-line usage give him the edge for now, especially in leagues that reward ice time and defensive stats.
Kirill Marchenko’s Fantasy Value for Next Season
Columbus forward Kirill Marchenko is trending upward, and fantasy managers should take notice. With his improved role and growing confidence, he could be a valuable mid-to-late round steal in next year’s drafts — especially in goal-heavy formats.
From bold underdog bets to long-term fantasy sleeper picks, The Cheat Sheet offered smart analysis and betting insights for every type of NHL fan. Whether you’re backing the underdogs, building DFS lineups, or placing a Conn Smythe future, this episode gave a sharp and easy-to-follow guide to navigating the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs.
