Even though the Toronto Maple Leafs had another disappointing exit from the Stanley Cup Playoffs, there was one major bright spot: the strong performance of veteran winger Max Pacioretty.
Despite only scoring five goals during the regular season due to injuries and salary cap issues, Pacioretty stepped up in the playoffs. He scored three goals and collected eight points in 11 games.
His most memorable moment was the series-winning goal against the Ottawa Senators in the first round. Now, reports suggest he is seriously thinking about returning to Toronto for another season.
Why Pacioretty Still Matters to the Leafs
At 36 years old, Pacioretty is not the same player he once was, but he brings experience, leadership, and toughness—qualities the Maple Leafs need more of. He’s had trouble staying healthy in recent years, but when he’s fit, he adds real value.
In this year’s playoffs, while some Leafs players faded under pressure—especially during the second round against the Florida Panthers—Pacioretty stood out. He adapted his playing style to remain effective, something many older players struggle to do. That shows his commitment and value to the team.
The Key: Smart Use and Load Management
If the Leafs do re-sign him, it shouldn’t be with the expectation that he’ll play every game. Instead, the goal should be to have him healthy and ready for the playoffs. Playing around 50 regular-season games would be ideal. Managing his minutes carefully and resting him when needed will be crucial.
Ice time is another area where the Leafs can make things work. Pacioretty is a flexible player who can fit into the second or third line depending on performance. With new coach Craig Berube in charge, Pacioretty’s role can be adjusted to get the best out of him without putting too much strain on his body.
What About the Contract?
Pacioretty played this season on a budget deal worth $873,770. After his strong playoff performance, he might expect a small raise. A bonus-based deal close to $1 million would make sense for both sides. It rewards his effort but still protects the team from the risk of injury.
But if winning the Stanley Cup is Pacioretty’s main goal, he may have to agree to a team-friendly deal. That would help the Leafs spend more on building a strong supporting team. And given his attitude this season, he doesn’t seem like the type to demand a big contract.
Will He Return to Toronto?
There’s always a chance that something could stop this reunion. Another team might offer him more money or a better role, or he might decide it’s time to retire if his body can’t keep up anymore.
However, Toronto gives him two important things: a familiar environment and a real chance to compete for the Cup. That’s something not every team can offer. If both sides can agree on a fair contract and smart usage, bringing back Max Pacioretty could be a smart move for the Leafs.
Max Pacioretty proved that he still has a lot to offer, especially during the high-pressure moments of the playoffs. The Leafs would benefit from his leadership and ability to handle big games, as long as they manage his health carefully. A short-term, bonus-heavy contract and smart game planning could make this a win-win for both Pacioretty and the Toronto Maple Leafs.
